CoMeal › Guides › Vegetarian + protein

Cooking for a vegetarian and a meat eater: one dinner for both

By CoMeal · Updated · 7 min read

The short answer

Cook the shared base of the meal vegetarian, then add the meat in a separate pan at the end for those who want it. Choose dishes where the protein is a topping, not the whole sauce, use vegetable stock, and check for hidden animal ingredients such as Parmesan, Worcestershire sauce and gelatine. One pot, one dinner, two kinds of plate.

If one person at your table is vegetarian and the rest eat meat, it is easy to end up cooking two dinners every night. You do not have to. This guide shows how to build one meal that works for both, which proteins to swap, which ingredients quietly contain meat or fish, and what a real week looks like.

How do you cook one meal for a vegetarian and a meat eater?

Make the base of the meal vegetarian, and cook the meat separately so it can be added to some plates at the end. Everyone shares the sauce, the vegetables and the carbs, and only the protein changes.

This works because most of a dinner is not the meat. A curry is mostly onion, spices, tomatoes and vegetables.

The basic method:

  1. Cook the base with vegetable stock and no meat: the sauce, the vegetables, the rice, pasta or potatoes.
  2. In a second pan, cook the meat with a little of the same seasoning.
  3. Cook the vegetarian protein (tofu, halloumi, beans or eggs) in a third pan, or stir pulses into a portion of the sauce.
  4. Serve the base, then add meat to some plates and the vegetarian protein to the others.

Use separate utensils and boards for the meat, and serve the vegetarian plates first so nothing gets mixed. For more on this way of cooking, see cook once, serve different plates.

Which dinners work best for vegetarians and meat eaters together?

The easiest dinners are the ones where the protein is a topping or a filling rather than the whole sauce. Build-your-own meals are the simplest of all, because each person puts their own plate together.

Good choices:

  • Tacos, fajitas and burritos: one tray of peppers and onions, chicken for some, black beans or halloumi for others.
  • Curries: one vegetable curry sauce, with chicken stirred into some bowls and chickpeas or paneer into others.
  • Stir-fries: one pan of vegetables and noodles, with beef strips and crispy tofu cooked separately.
  • Pasta: a tomato and vegetable sauce, with meatballs on the side for those who want them.
  • Grain bowls and jacket potatoes: shared bases with a choice of toppings.
  • Traybakes: two trays in the oven at once, sharing the same vegetables and seasoning.

Dishes that are harder to split include slow-cooked stews where the meat flavours the whole pot, and lasagne made with a meat ragù. You can still make them, but plan a second small dish, such as a lentil lasagne in a loaf tin.

What can you swap for meat in a shared meal?

Match the vegetarian swap to the job the meat is doing: chunks for chunks, mince for mince, something crispy for something crispy. The table below covers the most common swaps.

Meat in the recipeVegetarian swapWorks well in
Chicken piecesTofu, halloumi, paneer or chickpeasCurries, stir-fries, fajitas, traybakes
Beef minceGreen or brown lentils, kidney beans, or vegetarian minceChilli, bolognese, cottage pie, tacos
Steak or beef stripsPortobello mushrooms or crispy tofuStir-fries, sandwiches, noodle bowls
SausagesVegetarian sausages or butter beansTraybakes, casseroles, mash
Bacon or lardonsSmoked tofu, smoked paprika with mushroomsPasta, salads, risotto
Pulled porkJackfruit or shredded mushrooms in the same sauceWraps, buns, rice bowls
Fish fillet (for vegetarians)Halloumi, eggs or marinated tofuTraybakes, rice bowls, salads

A rough guide for portions is a palm-sized piece of protein per adult, or a cupped handful of cooked beans or lentils. Beans and pulses also count towards your 5 A Day, so meat eaters can happily have a spoonful too.

Swaps can bring in allergens: tofu and many vegetarian minces contain soya, halloumi and paneer are milk, and some vegetarian sausages and minces contain egg or gluten. If anyone has an allergy, check every label and follow their allergy specialist's advice. See meal planning with food allergies.

Which ingredients are not vegetarian?

Several everyday ingredients contain meat or fish even when the dish looks vegetarian. Check these before you call the base of a meal vegetarian.

  • Stock: chicken, beef and fish stock cubes and pots. Use vegetable stock for the shared base.
  • Parmesan: traditional Parmigiano Reggiano is made with animal rennet. Look for a vegetarian hard cheese labelled as suitable for vegetarians.
  • Other cheeses: Gorgonzola, Grana Padano and some others are often made with animal rennet. Check the label.
  • Worcestershire sauce: most contain anchovies. Vegetarian versions exist.
  • Gelatine: in some jellies, sweets, mousses, cheesecakes and yoghurts.
  • Fish sauce and shrimp paste: common in Thai and other South East Asian curry pastes.
  • Pesto: traditional pesto uses Parmesan.
  • Lard and suet: in some pastry, dumplings, mince pies and refried beans.

The simplest habit is to look for "suitable for vegetarians" on the packet. When in doubt, ask the person you are cooking for how strict they are. Some vegetarians are relaxed about rennet, many are not.

How does this work for vegan and pescatarian eaters?

The same method works: keep the shared base free of whatever the strictest eater avoids, and add the extras at the end. For a vegan, that means no dairy or eggs in the base. For a pescatarian, it means fish can be one of the add-ons.

For a vegan at the table, cook the base with oil rather than butter, skip cream in the sauce, and serve cheese, yoghurt and soured cream on the side. Tofu, beans, lentils and chickpeas cover the protein. Check bread, pastry and pasta, as some contain egg or milk.

For a pescatarian, you can offer prawns or salmon as their add-on, while the vegetarian has halloumi and the meat eaters have chicken. It is three proteins, but still one sauce and one pot of rice. If you are planning around more than two diets, read how to plan family meals when everyone eats differently.

An app like CoMeal does this for you: each person sets their diet as Everything, Vegetarian, Vegan, Pescatarian or No red meat, and the plan shows the swap on their plate from the same shared meal.

A worked example: one week for a mixed family of four

A mixed family can share every dinner of the week by keeping one base and changing only the protein on each plate. Here is a sample week for a family of four. Mum is vegetarian, Dad eats everything, their 14-year-old is pescatarian and their 9-year-old eats everything but does not like spicy food.

They plan five dinners, not seven, and leave two nights for leftovers or something simple.

DinnerShared baseDad and 9-year-oldMum14-year-old
Monday: fajitasPeppers, onions, wraps, salsa, yoghurtChicken stripsHalloumiPrawns
Tuesday: pastaTomato and courgette sauce, vegetarian hard cheeseMeatballsButter beans in the sauceButter beans in the sauce
Wednesday: curryMild vegetable curry sauce, riceChickenChickpeasChickpeas
Thursday: traybakePotatoes, red onion, broccoliSausagesVegetarian sausagesSalmon fillet
Saturday: noodle bowlsStir-fried vegetables and noodlesBeef stripsCrispy tofuCrispy tofu

On curry night, the sauce is mild, with chilli flakes on the table for the adults.

How do you shop for vegetarian and meat-eating diets in one list?

Write one list for the whole week, with the shared ingredients once and each protein listed separately. That way the base of every meal is bought in bulk, and nothing is bought twice.

For the week above, that means peppers, onions, tinned tomatoes, rice, noodles and wraps once, then each person's proteins.

CoMeal builds one shopping list from the week's plan, sorted by aisle and shared with the household, so anyone can tick things off. For more on this, see how to make one weekly shopping list for the whole household.

Common questions

Can vegetarians eat food cooked in the same pan as meat?

It depends on the person. Many vegetarians do not want their food cooked in the same pan or oil as meat, or touched by the same utensils. The safest approach is separate pans and spoons for the meat, and serving the vegetarian plates first. Ask the person what they are comfortable with.

Is Parmesan vegetarian?

Traditional Parmesan, or Parmigiano Reggiano, is not vegetarian because it is made with animal rennet. Supermarkets sell Italian-style hard cheeses made without animal rennet, labelled as suitable for vegetarians. Use one of these in any shared dish, and grate real Parmesan on the meat eaters' plates if they prefer it.

Will meat eaters be happy with a vegetarian base?

Usually, yes, because the base is just the sauce, vegetables and carbs they would eat anyway. The meat is still on their plate, cooked separately and added at the end. Dishes with strong flavour, such as curry, chilli and fajitas, are the easiest place to start.

How do I make sure a vegetarian gets enough protein?

Give the vegetarian a proper portion of a protein food at every meal, such as tofu, beans, lentils, eggs, halloumi or paneer, rather than just leaving the meat off their plate. A palm-sized portion, or a cupped handful of cooked pulses, is a useful rough guide. For specific needs, such as during pregnancy or for a growing child, follow advice from your GP or a dietitian.

Do I need separate recipes for vegetarians and meat eaters?

No. Most family recipes can be split by keeping the meat out of the main pot and cooking it on the side. Look for recipes where the protein is a topping or filling, and swap meat stock for vegetable stock. A separate recipe is only needed for dishes where the meat is the whole sauce, such as a slow-cooked beef stew.